Kone Corporation (patentee) v. INVENTIO AG et al. (opponents), Technical Board of Appeal 3.2.06, 4 May 2011, Case No. T 0144/09-3.2.06 with thanks to Stefan V. Steinbrener, Bardehle Pagenberg, for providing the case and summary
Technical Board of Appeal 3.2.06 holds a request inadmissible under Article 12(4) RPBA when added subject-matter held unallowable during proceedings before the opposition division is not removed at least by way of an auxiliary request filed in those proceedings, but only by way of a request filed during the appeal proceedings.
Read the decision (in English) here.
Read a summary in English provided by Bardehle Pagenberg, here.
« EU - Italy takes legal action against unitary patent protection | Main | DE - Calculation of damages for patent infringement on the basis of a substantially "increased" royalty rate »
08/06/2011
Comments
You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.
The comments to this entry are closed.
Search
Recent Comments
- BR on UK - Nestec v. Dualit (Nespresso)
- 8416519 on EU - Unitary Patent / Actions Spain and Italy against enhanced cooperation dismissed
- Sandeep on DE - Accord/Teva/Hexal v. AstraZeneca / Seroquel XR
- Tankred Thiem on EU - Agreement on a Unified Patent Court signed
- Konstantin Schallmoser on EU - Agreement on a Unified Patent Court signed
- Konstantin Schallmoser on EU - Unitary Patent / Final texts of the “patent package”
- Konstantin Schallmoser on EU - Unitary Patent / Final texts of the “patent package”
- Mark Richardson on EU - Unitary Patent / Final texts of the “patent package”
- Gibus on EU - Unitary Patent / Final texts of the “patent package”
- Rebentisch on EU - Exclusivity, Transitional Arrangements and Opt-out / Risk of financial disaster for small companies in patent litigation
Categories
- Liechtenstein
- A. Ten Cate Offsetprodukten
- Aabo
- Abbott
- Accord
- Accord Healthcare
- Actavis
- Active Photonics
- Added matter
- Afoheat
- AGA Medical Corporation & Ors
- Agfa Graphics
- Agilent
- AIPPI
- Ajinomoto
- Alcom
- Alcon Components
- Alendronat
- Alk-Abello
- Alkermes
- Amber Valley
- Amendments
- Amlodipine
- András Kupecz
- Angiotech
- Antitrust
- AP Racing
- Apimed Medical Honey
- Apotex
- Apothecon
- Apple
- Aranesp
- Arrow
- Art. 1369bis/6 Belgium Code of Civil Procedure
- Art. 56 Dutch Patent Act
- Art. 843a Dutch Code Civil Procedure
- Aspirin
- Astellas
- AstraZeneca
- Atorvastatin
- Auction
- Ausschreibung in Bulgarien
- Austria
- Aventis
- B + R Beheer
- Bayer
- Bayer CropScience
- Bayer Healthcare
- Beaphar
- Beckman Coulter
- Belgium
- Bericap
- Betson Medical
- Bidding in Bulgaria
- Bifurcation
- Biogaran
- Biogen
- Bioinformatics
- Biotech
- Blasenkatheterset
- Blücher
- Boehringer Ingelheim Pharma
- Boumatic
- breeders exemption
- Brigade
- Brightwake Limited
- Brüstle
- BSN
- Budapest
- Bundesgerichtshof
- Bureau voor de Industriele Eigendom
- Bébécar
- Calendar
- Cantideck
- Canusa
- Cease and desist
- Cefetra
- Cellectis
- Centocor
- Centraction
- Centrafarm
- CEVA
- Charlotte de Boer
- Chengdu Xinggraphics
- Chevron Phillips
- Chiron
- Cinfa
- Citalopram
- CJEU
- Clopidogrel
- Closest prior art
- Clyde Bergemann
- Colgate
- Combination patent
- Combination product
- Community patent
- Comptroller General of Patents
- Computer implemented inventions
- Confidentiality
- Conor
- Conquip Industrial
- Construct
- Contractual penalty
- Contributory Infringement
- Convatec
- Convention on Biological Diversity
- Cook Biotech
- Costs
- Counterfeit
- Crimpwerkzeug III (Crimping Tool III)
- Cross border
- Daiichi
- Damages
- Danisco
- DataCard
- Decree n° 2009-1205
- Delaval
- Delta
- Denmark
- Diagnostic Method
- Diamed
- Directive 98/44/EC
- Disclaimer
- Disclosure
- Discovery
- Docket
- Document Security System
- Dosages
- Double patenting
- Dr Reddy's
- Drawings
- Dreinahtschlauchfolienbeutel
- Drogisterij.net
- Druckmaschinen-Temperierungssystem III
- DSM Food Specialties
- DSM IP Assets
- Du Pont
- Dualit
- Due process
- Dusseldorf
- Dustcontrol
- Dynamic document generation
- Dynamische Dokumentengenerierung
- E-Plus
- e-Traction
- Eagle Technologies
- Earlex
- Easy Sanitary Solutions
- EBA
- ECJ
- Edwards Lifesciences
- EEX
- Einteilige Öse
- Eisai
- Electric arc lacing
- Electromagnetic Services
- Eli Lilly
- Employee invention
- Enantiomer
- Enforcement Directive
- Enhanced cooperation
- EPLAW
- EPO
- Equivalence
- Erik Ficks
- Error
- ERT
- Escitalopram
- Esomeprazol
- Etypharm
- EU
- EU Patent
- Euro Hair
- Eurogenerics
- European Central Bank
- European Patent Court
- EveryMed
- Ex Parte
- Exclusion to patentability
- Exhaustion
- Experimental use
- Ezendam
- Fatty acid composition
- Federal Patents Courts
- Fentanyl
- ferring
- Fettsäurezusammensetzung
- Fexofenadine
- File wrapper
- Finland
- Fischbissanzeiger
- Fish-bite indicator
- Fishing Expeditions
- Five year time bar
- Fluvastatin
- Flüssigkristallanzeigevorrichtung
- FOB
- France
- FRAND
- Frank Eijsvogels
- Free movement
- Furasen
- Furness
- FX Prevent
- Füllstoff
- G 1/08
- G 2/07
- Galantamine
- GE
- Geert Theuws
- Gelenkanordnung
- Gemstar
- Gene
- Genentech
- Generics
- GenOway
- Georgetown
- Germany
- Giellepi Chemicals
- Glasflaschenanalysesystem
- Glass bottle analyzing system
- Glaxo Group
- Gleitlagerüberwachung (plain bearing monitoring)
- Glenmark
- Global Bio-Chem Technology
- Global Factories
- Goedecke Aktiengesellschaft
- Great Lengths
- Greenpeace
- Grimme
- Grunenthal
- GSK
- GSM
- Hewlett-Packard
- Hexal
- High Point
- Hilding
- Hinge arrangement
- HL Display
- Holzhäcksler
- Honeywell
- Hospira
- HTC
- Huawei
- Human Genome Sciences
- Hungary
- Imminent infringement
- In re Bilski
- Indirect infringement
- Indspec
- Industrial application
- Industrial Self Adhesives
- Ineos
- Inescapable trap
- Infringement
- Injunction
- Institut Pasteur
- Insufficiency
- Intas Pharmaceuticals
- Interiors Manufacturing
- Internal gear hub I
- Internal gear hub II
- Interpretation
- Interver
- Intervet
- Invalidity
- Inventive step
- Inventive step - secondary indicia
- IPCom
- ISCC
- Italian torpedo
- Italy
- Iverness Medical
- Janssen
- Jodosulfuron
- John Bean
- Johnson&Johnson
- Jurenco Equipment
- Jurisdiction
- KCI
- Kedge
- Kirin Amgen
- KPN
- Kubus
- Laboratoires Medidom
- Laboratoires Negma
- Laboratorios Rubió
- Languages
- Lankhorst
- LCD
- Leflunomide
- Leistungshalbleiterbauelement
- Lely
- LEO Pharma
- Les Laboratoires Servier
- LG
- Liability shipping company
- License
- Lichtbogenschnürung
- LightAir Holding
- Limitation
- Linco
- Lizzano
- Lommers-Van Eijken Tuinouwmachines
- London agreement
- London Protocol
- Losartan
- Lotus Bakeries
- Lovells
- LPC Group
- Lucheng
- Lundbeck
- Magaldi
- Mannheim Regional Court
- Manufacturing Fiction
- Maschinensatz (Machine assembly)
- Maurizio Bindi
- Max Planck
- Maxi Miliaan
- MBrands
- Mcneil
- Meda Pharma
- Medeva
- MedImmune
- Medinol
- Medtronic CoreValve
- Memantine
- Merck
- Merck Sharp & Dohme
- Merckle GmbH
- Merial
- Meridian Medical
- Merz
- Method claim
- Metropolitan Court
- Meyn
- Microsoft
- Middenweg
- Molnlycke
- Monsanto
- Morality
- Morocco
- Mosadex
- Motorola
- Multispike
- Mundipharma
- Mylan
- N.O.B.
- Nabenschaltung I
- Nabenschaltung II
- Nampak Cartons
- Nebivolol
- nebivolol
- Neolab
- Nespresso
- Neurim Pharmaceuticals (1991)
- New claim on appeal
- Newell Rubbermaid
- niconovum
- Nokia
- Norway
- Novartis
- Novelty
- Novozymes
- Obviousness
- Occlutech
- Offer
- Olanzapine
- Omnipharm
- Ophthalmic lens
- Opposition
- Ordre Public
- Otis
- Otter Ultra Low Drag Limited
- Oxycodone
- OxyContin®
- Paediatric
- Pallet Container II
- Paroxetine
- Patent Box
- Patent Court Agreement
- Pelargonium
- Perini
- Perlin
- Person skilled in the art
- Persson
- Pfizer
- Pharma Change
- Pharmachemie
- Phil & Ted's
- Philippe de Jong
- Philips
- Pioneer invention
- Plant variety
- Pneumatisches Schlagwerkzeug
- Polymerisierbare Zementmischung
- Population Diagnostics
- Postech
- Pozzoli
- PPG Industries
- Pralinenform II
- Premium
- Primus
- Prior use
- Priority
- problem-solution approach
- Prosecution file
- Pullman-Ermator
- Qualimed
- Ranbaxy
- Rapid Action Packaging
- Ratiopharm
- Recall
- Regeneron
- Regulation (EC) No. 44/2001
- Regulation 1383/2003
- Regulation 1768/1992
- Regulation 1901/2006
- Regulation 2309/93
- Regulation 3295/94
- Regulation 469/2009
- Reminyl
- Renewal
- Repair
- reprise
- Research Corporation Technologies
- Research exception
- Research exemption
- Rheon
- Rhodia
- RIM
- Rivastigmine
- Roche
- Roche Diagnostics
- Rome II
- roof security
- Roquette Frères
- Rovi
- Ruud Peters
- Safeway
- Saip&Schyller
- Saisie Contrefaçon
- Samsonite
- Samsung
- Sandoz
- Sanofi
- Sanofi Aventis
- Sanquin
- Schenck Rotec
- Schindler
- Schlumberger
- Schneider
- Schreurs
- Schutz
- Scope of Protection
- Scott
- Sektionaltor
- Selection patent
- Sepracor
- Seroquel
- Sharp
- Sick IVP
- Siemens
- Sigma
- Single European Patent Court
- Sisvel
- Smith & Nephew
- Smith & Nephew
- SmithKline Beecham
- Solo
- Solvay
- Sony
- Spain
- SPC
- Springboard effect
- Stallergenes
- Standard
- Steenvoorden
- Stiftelsen SINTEF
- Stopaq
- Street Surfing
- Sufficiency
- Sumitomo Bakelite Europe
- Sweden
- Switzerland
- Synaptech
- Synco
- Synthon
- Tate & Lyle Technology
- TBA
- Tecno
- Tede
- Teisseire
- Teknek
- Telekommunikationseinrichtung
- Telenet
- Teriflunomide
- Teva
- The Netherlands
- Thermoplastic composition
- Thermoplastische Zusammensetzung
- Tiefenbacher
- Torbjørn Kvassheim
- Torpedo
- Traditional knowledge
- Tramadol
- Transit
- Translation
- TRIPS
- Ulti Med Products
- UMTS
- Unfair competition
- Unified Patent Court
- Unilever
- Unitary Patent
- United Kingdom
- United States
- United video
- Universal Balancing
- Unregistered license
- Upcycle
- Vacu Products
- Valsartan
- Van Beelen Industrie
- Van den Berg Beton Kelders B.V.
- Van der Lande
- Van Riet
- Vanserum
- Verfahren zur Lagerung von Stückgut
- Vermop Salmon
- Vernacare
- Vetrotech
- Viagra
- Virgin
- Vollstreckungsschaden
- Wagner
- Walzenformgebungsmaschine
- Walzgerüst II (Rolling Stand II)
- Warner-Lamber
- Waters
- Wellcome
- Werit
- Willem Hoyng
- Willems Biscuiterie
- Wim Maas
- WMF
- Wonderland
- Xena
- Xingraphics
- Yeda
- Young EPLAW
- Yozmot
- Ziggo
- Ziuz
- ZTE
A similar decision made by another Board is T23/10 :
see http://tinyurl.com/6kx7sq7
Posted by: Laurent Teyssèdre | 15/06/2011 at 12:18